Most “solar vs. generator” articles pick a winner. After years of wiring RVs in Tucson, here’s the straighter answer: solar should carry your everyday power, and a generator should be your backup for the big loads, mainly the air conditioner. For most people who camp off-grid, the right setup is both, wired so they work together.
The Short Answer
If you mostly camp off-grid in mild weather and want quiet, hands-off power for lights, the fridge, fans, laptops, CPAP and the coffee maker, solar with a lithium battery bank does that better than a generator. It runs silently, costs nothing to run once it’s in, and keeps working while you’re hiking or asleep. If you need to run a roof air conditioner for hours, especially in an Arizona summer, a generator (or shore power) is still the practical answer. The best systems use solar for the daily load and let the generator top off the batteries and carry the AC when you need it.
Solar vs. Generator at a Glance
| Solar + lithium batteries | Generator | |
|---|---|---|
| Noise | Silent | Noticeable. Even quiet inverter generators are audible at the next site |
| Running cost | None once installed | Fuel every day you run it, plus oil changes and service |
| Upfront cost | Higher | Lower for a portable unit |
| Runs a roof AC for hours | Only with a very large battery bank and inverter | Yes, that’s what it’s best at |
| Works at night | Yes, from stored battery power | Yes, but quiet hours often say no |
| Campground rules | No restrictions | Many campgrounds and parks limit generator hours |
| Maintenance | Keep panels clean, check connections | Oil, filters, carburetor or fuel system care, exercise it monthly |
| Hands-off | Yes, charges on its own | Someone has to start it, fuel it and watch the hours (unless you add auto start) |
What Does Solar Do Better Than a Generator?
Solar wins on everything you use all day, every day. A properly sized system with lithium batteries will run your 12V fridge, lights, water pump, fans, furnace blower, phones, laptops and a CPAP night after night without you thinking about it. There’s no noise, no fumes, no fuel to haul, and no quiet hours to work around. Your batteries refill on their own while you’re out exploring.
Solar also changes how you use a generator. Instead of running it for hours just to keep the batteries alive, you run it only when you need a big load, which means less fuel, less noise and fewer service hours. If you want to know how many days you can go on solar alone, we walk through it in how long you can boondock on solar alone.
What Does a Generator Still Do Better?
A generator makes a lot of power on demand, rain or shine, day or night. That matters for three things:
- Roof air conditioners. An RV AC is the biggest load in the rig and it runs for hours at a time. Solar on a typical RV roof can’t keep up with that on its own.
- Long stretches of clouds or short winter days. Solar output drops on cloudy days and in winter. A generator refills the bank no matter the weather.
- Lower upfront cost. A portable inverter generator costs less up front than a full solar and lithium system. You pay for it later in fuel and hours.
For reference, Honda lists its popular EU2200i at 48 to 57 dB(A) and 3.2 to 8.1 hours of runtime on a 0.95-gallon tank, depending on load. That’s quiet for a generator, but it’s still a running engine next to your campsite.
Can Solar Run My RV Air Conditioner?
It can start and run one, but running it for hours is a different question. With a soft start on the AC and a large enough inverter, a lithium bank can power a roof AC. The catch is runtime: an AC runs for hours, and every hour pulls a big chunk of your battery bank. Running one all night takes a very large bank, and the roof usually can’t hold enough panels to refill it the next day in an Arizona summer.
What we do on most Tucson installs: size the system so the batteries can run the AC for the hours that matter (an afternoon nap, a short stop, the first part of the evening), and let the generator or shore power carry long AC runs. If overnight AC on batteries is a must for you, tell us up front. It can be done, but it’s a much bigger system, and we’ll tell you honestly what it takes. Our guide to how much solar you need shows the math.
Why Most of Our Customers Keep Both
Most of the rigs we work on still have their generator after the solar install, and that’s on purpose. The two work best together:
- Solar carries the daily load. Lights, fridge, fans, electronics and the coffee maker come off the battery bank.
- The generator becomes backup. A Victron MultiPlus-II inverter/charger can charge the batteries from the generator and pass power through to the RV, so an hour of generator time refills the bank instead of babysitting it all day. More on that in our RV inverter/charger installation page.
- Auto start, if you want it. On rigs with an onboard generator, an auto generator start can fire it up when the batteries get low and shut it off when they’re full, within the quiet hours you set.
- Soft starts make the AC easier on everything. A soft start lowers the AC’s startup surge, so it starts on a smaller generator or on the inverter.
How Do I Decide Between Solar and a Generator?
Answer these four questions:
- Do you need AC for hours at a time? If yes, keep or add a generator, and add solar for everything else.
- How do you camp? Mostly hookups with a few nights off-grid: a modest solar setup or a portable generator is enough. Weeks off-grid on public land: solar with lithium pays you back in quiet and fuel.
- Do quiet hours or generator rules limit you? If you camp in parks or campgrounds with generator hours, solar covers the times you can’t run it.
- How hands-off do you want it? Solar charges on its own. A generator needs someone to start it, fuel it and service it.
If you’re still not sure, our complete RV boondocking power guide walks through a full off-grid setup from batteries to inverter.
FAQ
Can I add solar and keep my onboard generator?
Yes. That’s the most common setup we install. The solar and battery system wires in alongside the generator, and an inverter/charger lets the generator recharge the batteries when you need it.
How much solar do I need to stop running my generator every day?
It depends on your daily loads, your battery bank and the season. For most rigs without AC loads, a right-sized solar array and lithium bank cover the daily load in good sun. Our free 2-minute RV solar size check gives you a number for your rig.
Does RV solar work in an Arizona winter?
Yes, with less output. Winter days are shorter and the sun is lower, so panels make less power than in summer. We size systems with that in mind, and a generator covers the cloudy stretches.
Is solar worth the higher upfront cost?
If you camp off-grid often, usually yes: you trade fuel, noise and generator hours for quiet power. If you’re mostly on hookups, maybe not. We break it down in is RV solar worth it and how much RV solar costs.
Get a Straight Answer for Your Rig
Every rig and every camping style is different. Tell us what you run and how you camp, and we’ll tell you whether solar, a generator or both makes sense, and what size. Start with the free RV solar size check, or call or text Chris at 520-910-1237. We install at your RV park or site anywhere in the Tucson area.
